Rounds are rounds they will be kept THIS year i.e. including inflation (except undrafted which I've just noted as "undrafted"), but everyone should check their own team...
Andrew:
Miguel Cabrera (1st round)
Alex Rios (9th round)
Evan Longoria (26th round)
Jacoby Ellsbury (22nd)
Carl Crawford (2nd round)
Prospect- Matt Wieters (undrafted)
Luke:
Daisuke Matsuzaka (6th round)
Josh Beckett (8th round)
Ervin Santana (undrafted)
Nelson Cruz (undrafted)
Carlos Quentin (undrafted)
Prospect Pick: Taylor Teagarden (undrafted)
Mark:
Sizemore (1st)
Morneau (2nd)
Roberts (4th)
Granderson (11th)
Hamilton (12th)
Prospect: Price: (drafted 22nd but released then picked up so undrafted)
Caleb:
Roy Halladay - (Round 6)
James Shields - (Round 7)
Jhonny Peralta - (Round 10)
Cliff Lee - undrafted
Chris Davis - undrafted
Prospect Pick: Lars Anderson (undrafted)
Spencer:
A-Roid (1st round)
Carlos Pena (22nd round)
Joba Chamberlian (23rd round)
Liriano (18th round)
Youkilis (10th round)
Prospect: Travis Snider (undrafted)
Bill:
Pedroia (9th)
Kinsler (10th)
Markakis (13th)
BJ Upton (16th)
Alexei Ramirez (undrafted)
Devine (undrafted), prospect
5 comments:
Let's go with the analysis already.
I think my keepers are the weakest. I think Bill has the best value (quality relative to draft position), but that Andrew's ended up with the best overall set of keepers.
Discuss.
Actually, it's a tossup between Andrew and Bill for overall quality. And Bill got better value, so he wins.
while I appreciate you trying to take the bullet Caleb, I think it's clear that MY keepers are the weakest. at least you have some potential assets for the future.
Bill has better value, I'd say, and he has cornered the market on middle infielders. Boy, do I wish I'd held on to Pedroia.
All told, I'm very happy with my keepers, especially considering I dealt one player for a 3rd round pick. I do think I have the best values, especially because all of my offensive players chip in a little in all 5 categories. That said, I don't have a surefire top pick, a Cabrera, A-Rod, or a Sizemore. Mark's keepers will probably put up the best stats, but filling 3 OF positions, as well as using up 3 of his first 5 picks, that is probably necessary.
As for who has the weakest keepers, I think it is Spencer or Luke. For the pitchers, Matsuzaka, Beckett, Chamberlain, and Liriano all have pretty big question marks surrounding them, whereas Shields and Halladay are pretty solid. Nelson Cruz, who is Luke's only potential 5 tool player, could be useful, but he could also end up in AAA. Pena isn't very risky, but could be a big drag due to batting average. Then again, having A-Rod certainly does help. So, sorry Luke, I'm going to have to go with you.
Post a Comment